Home
The Trilateral
Cooperation
News / Service
Management
Monitoring
 
The information on this site is subject to a disclaimer.
 
TMAP Implementation  
 

TMAP Implementation Plan 
(December 1997)

In 1997, the Trilateral Monitoring and Assessment Group (TMAG) elaborated a proposal on the implementation of the Trilateral Monitoring and Assessment Program (TMAP) of the Wadden Sea. This report is the basis for the decisions at the Trilateral Governmental Conference regarding the adoption of a "Common Package" of monitoring parameters.

The work was carried out by the DEMOWAD project (April 1995 - June 1998) co-financed by the EC under the LIFE- Program.

Preface and Executive Summary are available as html-file.
The full version of the report including the annexes is available as pdf-files.

Preface (html)

0. Executive Summary (html)

Download all chapters (only pdf, 155 K),
please note: Annexes are in separate files.

CONTENTS:

Preface
0. Executive Summary
1. Introduction
2. The Parameters
3. The Costs
4. Data Handling
5. Ecologcial Research
6. TMAP: Organizational Structure

ANNEXES:

Download Annex 1 (pdf, 52 K):

ANNEX 1: TMAP Issues of Concern and Parameters (pdf, 52 K)

Download Annex 2 - 4 (pdf, 100 K):

ANNEX 2: Ecological Targets and Targets on Cultural and Historical Aspects
ANNEX 3: Parameters List of the TMAP - Priority Setting
ANNEX 4: List of TMAP Parameter Groups and Priorities for their Implementation

Download Annex 5 - 6 (pdf, 100 K):

ANNEX 5: Information Quality of TMAP Parameters: Ecotargets and TMAP Hypotheses
ANNEX 6: Cost Estimation and Information Quality of A-Parameter Groups

Download Annex 7 (pdf, 106 K):

ANNEX 7: Data Handling and the Anticipated Implementation Effort

 TMAP Implementation Plan

December 1997

 

PREFACE

 

1. Decision of the Stade Conference on the TMAP implementation

The report "Implementation of the Trilateral Monitoring and Assessment Program (TMAP)" was elaborated by the Trilateral Monitoring and Assessment Group (TMAG) in fulfillment of §67 of the Leeuwarden Declaration (1994). The work has been carried out in the framework of the DEMOWAD project co-financed by the European Commission under the LIFE Program.

The report entails proposals on the implementation of the different parts of the Wadden Sea monitoring program by defining priority parameter groups and developing implementation scenarios taking into account technical and financial implications.

In the framework of the preparation of the Eighth Trilateral Governmental Conference (TGC) in Stade (Germany) in October 1997, a draft version of this report was considered by the Trilateral Working Group (TWG) and the Senior Officials (SO).

As a result of the negotiations, a proposal for the implementation of a common package of TMAP parameters was elaborated based on the minimum proposal of the TMAG, stated in its report (the so-called "A-minus-scenario"), and presented to the Stade Conference.

At the Stade Conference, the Ministers expressed their appreciation about the work exercised by the TMAG in elaborating the report. They agreed to implement the common package of parameters as in Table 1 and, to this end, establish, as soon as possible, the necessary financial and organizational preconditions for its implementation including the associated data management (Stade Declaration §§ 20 - 21).

The Ministers also agreed to an evaluation of experiences with this common package at the next Wadden Sea Conference (Stade Declaration § 22) (see: TMAP Evalution Report, February 2001).

2. Present status of the TMAP

The development of the TMAP has made considerable progress since the publication of the draft report in April 1997:

A common package of TMAP parameters have been adopted by the Ministers and will be implemented together with the associated data management as laid down in the report. It covers all important categories of Wadden Sea monitoring except microbiological parameters (mainly because of technical limitations). Several parameters which were monitored only in one or two countries in regular programs will now be monitored in all three countries using common guidelines. Furthermore, the parameter 'Contaminants in Bird Eggs' will be implemented as a completely new parameter group in regular Wadden Sea monitoring.

A TMAP Manual entailing guidelines of selected parameter groups have been adopted. Modifications were agreed regarding the TMAP guidelines which, in most cases, are minor changes to the proposed draft guidelines. Activities have already started to implement these guidelines into the national monitoring programs, including the associated data management, and to organize the coordinated assessment of the derived monitoring data.

The prototype of a TMAP data management system was developed and installed in each country as described in the report. For two selected parameter groups, the prototype has successfully demonstrated the functionality of the trilateral data exchange and can be accessed via the Internet (TMAP Data Unit). In all Wadden Sea countries structures will be set up to maintain and further develop this prototype.

3. The TMAP and the Wadden Sea Plan

At the Trilateral Governmental Conference in Stade in October 1997, a management plan, the Trilateral Wadden Sea Plan, was adopted. The plan aims at implementing the common ecological targets and targets on cultural and historical aspects. The plan is structured according to the target categories. For each target category, a trilateral policy and a common management strategy have been adopted, as well as, trilateral projects and actions, necessary for the implementation of the targets.

The TMAP is an important instrument of the Wadden Sea Plan when evaluating the progress made in implementing the targets. Based on the common package of the TMAP, basic information about the status of most of the targets will be obtained because the targets were the major criteria for the selection of the parameter groups of the common package. Common monitoring strategies and assessment procedures, as well as, a modern data exchange system will make the required information faster and easier available than in the past.

The TMAP also supports the Wadden Sea Plan by making the results of monitoring available to relevant authorities, interest groups and local citizens as laid down in the Wadden Sea Plan (Chapter I, § 15). Furthermore, the Internet website of the Common Wadden Sea Secretariat (CWSS) supports a more effective communication and information regarding the implementation of the Wadden Sea Plan.

Table 1: Common Package TMAP. The parameters in the Common Package will be monitored according to the agreed common TMAP Guidelines (see TMAP Manual)

Contaminants 1 TBT in water and sediment
2 Metals in sediment
Nutrients 3 Inorganic nutrients in water
Salt Marshes 4 Spatial extension
5 Agricultural utilization: grazing
Benthos 6 Macroalgae
7 Eelgrass
8 Macrozoobenthos communities
9 Blue Mussel beds
10 Contaminants in Blue Mussel
Plankton 11 Phytoplankton
Fish 12 Contaminants in flounder
13 Mussel/Cockle/Shrimp fishery
Beaches and Dunes 14 Spatial extension
Birds 15 Breeding birds: numbers and distribution
16 Breeding birds: contaminants in bird eggs
17 Migratory birds: numbers of waterbirds in counting units
18 Beached Bird Survey (BBS)
Seals 19 Population parameters by aerial survey
Recreational Activities 20 Boats at sea
22 No. of guided tours
23 Air traffic
General Parameters 24 Coastal protection measures
25 Geomorphology
26 Flooding
27 Land use
28 Weather conditions
28 Hydrology

 
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The further development of the monitoring methodology and the data handling for the TMAP made considerable progress during 1997. The work was carried out in a project called DEMOWAD" which is running until March 1998 and is being co-financed by the European Commission under the LIFE- NATURE program.

A TMAP Manual entailing guidelines of selected parameter groups and a functioning prototype of a data exchange system were presented to the 8th Trilateral Governmental Conference in Stade, Germany, 22 October 1997. The Ministers adopted a common package of monitoring parameters and decided to establish the necessary financial and organizational preconditions for its implementation including the associated data management.

1 The Common Package of Parameters

The TMAP parameters were deduced from defined monitoring objectives (TMAP Issues of Concern, Ecological Targets). During trilateral expert workshops in 1995 and 1996, proposals were made on monitoring methods for all parameter groups ("Wadden Sea Ecosystem" No. 6, 1996).

Because of technical and financial restrictions, only selected parts of the parameter groups will be applied. The selection of parameters for this "common package" were made on the basis of defined criteria which cover the technical effort for the implementation, the relative importance for the respective TMAP Issues of Concern and the Ecological Targets. The "common package" together with the TMAP guidelines were endorsed by the 8th Trilateral Governmental Wadden Sea Conference in Stade, Germany, October 1997, as part of the Ministerial Declaration (see Annex 1).

This will guarantee that an appropriate base of information concerning the most important questions of the TMAP will readily be available for the assessment. The contents of the "common package" will be regularly evaluated. Having the appropriate conditions in place, further parameter groups may gradually be added, thus increasing the information quality of the monitoring program. This procedure secures that the TMAP will continuously be adapted to the needs of the trilateral policies.

2 TMAP Manual

The TMAP Manual entails information about the TMAP (objectives, structure, assessment), the TMAP guidelines and the TMAP Data Management. A first draft version of the Manual was presented at the Stade Conference and was modified according to the decisions taken at the Conference.

The TMAP guidelines referred as much as possible to the JAMP guidelines adopted by ASMO 1997 in order to enhance mutual benefit and to avoid redundancies. Assessment tools like ecotoxicological assessment criteria, background/reference concentrations and the Common Procedure for the Identification of the Eutrophication Status will also be used in the TMAP assessment.

TMAP guidelines for monitoring of soft bottom macrozoobenthos were elaborated referring to the JAMP guideline (JAMP Eutrophication Monitoring Guidelines: Benthos, Technical Annex 2).

3 Data Management

An elementary component of the TMAP is common data management through which monitoring data are made available. This data management system will be implemented with the individual monitoring parameters. For this purpose, databases will be installed in each country where the appropriate Wadden Sea data will be uniformly stored. The monitoring data will then be more readily available in a shorter span of time as in the past. Also, all the information which is necessary for the interpretation of the data is part of the database and will also be available for downloading. The trilateral data exchange system was developed by "DEMOWAD" project (running from 1 April 1995 to 31 March 1998, co-financed by the European Commission under the LIFE program).

A prototype of this system was finalized and tested in 1997. Breeding bird counts and metal concentrations in blue mussels were used as test data. The first practical experiences have been available since the summer of 1997 and they prove the functionality of the system. An overview of the data can be found in the data catalogue which can also be reached on the Internet by the public. The downloading of data is restricted to selected expert groups who are responsible for assessing and publishing said data.

4 Assessment Report of the Wadden Sea Ecosystem

On the occasion of the 8th Trilateral Governmental Wadden Sea Conference, Stade, Germany, 22 October 1997, an Assessment of the Wadden Sea Ecosystem was published. The report is based upon material, contributed by a large number of experts in the past two years. These contributions will be published in the second half of 1998 in the full Wadden Sea Quality Status Report which will be timely available for the Regional North Sea QSR of OSPAR.

The assessment is structured according to the habitats as defined at the 7th Trilateral Governmental Wadden Sea Conference, Leeuwarden, The Netherlands, 1994. It concerns the tidal area, the salt marshes, the estuaries, the beaches and dunes and the North Sea offshore zone. Each of these chapters starts with a definition of the habitat and the relevant ecological targets. A separate chapter on birds and seals was added because these species groups use more than one habitat. The habitat type 'rural area' is addressed in this chapter as well. The report starts with a chapter on the quality of water, sediment and biota.

The actual assessment focuses on the status of the ecotargets.

In the last chapter the main issues of concern, identified in the 1993 Quality Status Report, are reevaluated on the basis of new knowledge and insights.

 

 

Home | Trilateral Cooperation | News/Service |
Management | Monitoring | Interregional Cooperation