|
Introduction
As part of the JMMB program, trends of 34 waterbird species for the
international Wadden Sea and the four regions - The Netherlands, the Federal
States of Germany, Niedersachsen/ Hamburg and Schleswig-Holstein, and Denmark
will be presented.
Data and methods
Data used in the analyses are a mixture of total counts (two
internationally, up to five nationally) and counts of a selection of sites
which are counted more frequently (12-25 times a season). At present a total
of 594 counting units are defined in the Wadden Sea, which are included in
the analyses. For this report, the original counting data, available at the
smallest level have been used.
Trends are calculated and presented for 34 waterbird species. These are
species which use the Wadden Sea during stop-over on migration or as a
wintering area with large parts of their flyway population. Species which
only occur in low numbers or species which cannot be counted with sufficient
representativeness have been excluded from the analyses (for a more detailed
explanation see Rösner et al., 1994).
Despite a large dataset with lots of real count data available also missing
counts are present. A complete dataset involves counts for all counting
units in all months of the year.To analyse the waterbird count data, UINDEX
(Bell, 1995) was used to account for missing counts in the dataset, and then
TrendSpotter is applied to calculate trends (Visser, 2004, Soldaat et al
2007). The program UINDEX is estimating bird numbers for missing counts
(imputing) taking into account site- ,year- and month-factors (Underhill &
Prys-Jones 1994). Sites are grouped in four regional strata representing the
four different Wadden Sea “countries”. The counted and imputed values for
each month are added to yearly averages for the respective “bird-years”,
covering the period from July to June of the following year (Figure 1).
After that with the program TrendSpotter so-called “flexible trends” are
calculated. These are particularly suitable for time series data with
different periods of decreasing, stable or increasing trends (Visser 2004,
Soldaat et al., 2007). A trend line calculated by TrendSpotter hardly
deviates from a moving average or a smoothed trend line as calculated by a
Generalized Additive Model (GAM) (e.g. Atkinson et al., 2006). TrendSpotter
calculates also confidence intervals and differences between the trend level
of the last year and each of the preceding years can be assessed (Soldaat et
al. 2007). This way trend estimates can be given for any period, as for
example the last 10 years and the whole time period, as in the current
analyses.

Figure 1. Example of the treatment of data for the trend
analyses. First the seasonal pattern is reconstructed by using counted
numbers and imputed numbers for each month for a certain species (left graph
of the figure, dark blue is counted, light blue is imputed). Than the
average over all months is taken and this is the ‘yearly estimate’ to be
used in the trend analyses (right graph). The trend line and confidence
limits are calculated over all year estimates.
Acknowledgements
In Denmark the counts were carried out by the National Environmental
Research Institute (NERI, University of Aarhus). Aerial counts were
carried out by NERI up to 1992, and during the years after they were
organized through a collaboration between NERI and Ribe
Environmental Center, Ministry of the Environment.
In Schleswig-Holstein the monitoring was initiated by the
Ornithological Society Schleswig-Holstein (OAG SH) in the 1960s;
regular monitoring was jointly organized by the OAG SH and the World
Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) in 1987 and during the first period until
1994 funded by the federal state Schleswig-Holstein and the Federal
Ministry of Environment (Federal Environment Agency) as part of an
ecosystem research project. Since then it was funded by the National
Park Administration Schleswig-Holstein Wadden Sea. The coordination
of the project moved from WWF to the Schutzstation Wattenmeer e.V.
in 2004. The aerial surveys of Common Eider and Shelduck were
separately financed by the National Park Administration
Schleswig-Holstein Wadden Sea.
In Niedersachsen and the Hamburg regions the counts were organized
by the Bird Conservation Station in the Lower Saxony Water
Management, Coastal Defence and Nature Conservation Agency (NLWKN),
formerly Lower Saxony Agency for Ecology (NLÖ). The aerial surveys
of Common Eider were financed by the Lower Saxony Wadden Sea
National Park Authority.
The waterbird counts in the Dutch Wadden Sea are part of the
national monitoring program of waterbirds in The Netherlands, which
is a cooperation between the Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and
Food Quality, the Ministry of Water Management and Public Works,
Statistics The Netherlands (CBS), Vogelbescherming Nederland and
SOVON Dutch Centre for Field Ornithology. The aerial surveys of
Common Eider were carried out under the responsibility of the
Ministry of Water Management and Public Works.
|